Skip to content
GET A DEMO
All posts

How to Use AI in Marketing Without Losing Authenticity (And Other Questions You’re Asking in 2025)

Picture of Joe Wilson   Joe Wilson  ·  3 minute read

Blog AI Marketing

The Question Everyone’s Asking: “How do I use AI in marketing without losing authenticity?”
 
It’s the number one question I hear from sales and marketing pros right now, and for good reason.
 
The internet is drowning in machine-made content. It’s faster, cheaper, and everywhere. But it’s also created what many are calling "AI fatigue"…that exhaustion you feel from content that looks perfect, but feels empty.
 
Ninety percent of consumers say authenticity matters when choosing who to work with. If you’re in a relationship-based business like mortgage, real estate, or financial services, that number should make you pause. Trust is your currency.
 
The good news is you can leverage AI without losing your voice or credibility. And while we’re at it, let’s answer a few other big questions you’re probably asking too.
 


⚠️ How Do I Use AI in Marketing Without Losing Authenticity?

Treat AI like a co-pilot, not the driver.  Use it for speed — idea generation, formatting, content scheduling — but keep the storytelling, nuance, and personality human.
 
 Run everything through your “coffee test.” If you wouldn’t say it naturally over coffee with a client, rewrite it.
 
 Where SocialCoach fits: We give you tools to ideate, organize, and schedule content...but the human connection is always yours. You stay in the driver’s seat.
 
 

⚖️ What’s the Right Balance Between AI and Human Content?

Think in terms of content zones:

  • Human-Only Zone (High Trust): Client stories, opinion posts, live videos, personal reflections

  • AI-Okay Zone (Low Trust): Formatting, resizing, market data summaries, hashtag research

  • Blend Zone: Scripts, captions, newsletters — AI drafts, you personalize

Aim for at least 50% of your content to be human-only in visible ways – like video, photos, and storytelling.

 

🤔 Why Does AI-Generated Content Feel Fake, and How Do I Fix It?

AI often produces “averages” that feel basic, generic, and over-polished. It lacks lived experience, which is why readers struggle to see themselves in it.
 
The fix is simple: add specifics.
 
Names, places, real client scenarios, imperfect moments.
 
Even in AI-assisted posts, include one detail no machine could know — a line from a client conversation, a local reference, or a behind-the-scenes photo.

 

👨‍💻 What Should I Keep Human, and What Can I Automate?

Keep Human:
  • Relationship touchpoints like DMs, thank-you videos, and introductions
  • Thought leadership and hot takes
  • Any visual of you speaking directly to your audience
Automate:
  • Post timing and distribution
  • Market recaps and templated updates
  • Content repurposing across platforms
Blend:
  • Campaign concepts, video outlines, multi-post sequences
Where SocialCoach fits: Automate the repetitive, time-consuming pieces of the process (such as spending an hour manually copying and pasting your post to each social media platform) so you can focus on your high-trust, human moments.
 

🙅 Is AI Killing Trust in Social Selling?

Not if you use it right. The sellers losing trust are the ones who disappear from their own marketing. If every post looks and sounds like a template, prospects will feel it and scroll past.
 
The future belongs to those who:
  • Use AI to remove friction, not connection
  • Show their face, voice, and perspective regularly
  • Make technology invisible so relationships stay front and center
 

📝 Your 2025 Playbook

 
AI is here to stay, and it’s not the enemy. The real danger is thinking you can outsource trust to a machine.The formula for winning in 2025 is simple:
  1. Use AI for efficiency
  2. Keep your human touch where trust is built
  3. Let tools like SocialCoach handle the busywork so you can focus on what matters most — being you
If you want to go deeper on how to do this, join our Free Social Selling Boot Camp. We’ll walk you through how to build a personal brand, create engaging content, and optimize your profile to show up in searches so you become a top social seller.
 
You’ll leave with real strategies you can use immediately, plus you’ll see how easy it can be to create and share content with SocialCoach.


📩 Want tips like this delivered straight to your inbox?

For more social media strategies built for mortgage and real estate pros, click here to subscribe to our newsletter.

We’ll send you our best insights every two weeks – no fluff, just actionable advice.

 

📲 What you get with SocialCoach

See how to save time and make social media feel easy with SocialCoach →

With SocialCoach, we make it easy to take what you’re already saying and turn it into content that works twice as hard:

    • Struggling to come up with what to say? → Use our prewritten scripts based on the exact questions buyers and homeowners are searching online.

    • Feel awkward on camera or frustrated by too many retakes? → Our built-in teleprompter helps you speak naturally and record confidently in fewer takes.

    • Don't have hours to spend editing, but still want your videos to look polished? → Our team does it for you by cutting out mistakes, adding captions, creating a thumbnail, and making your video look professional so you feel confident sharing it.
    • Tired of posting inconsistently or forgetting altogether? → Schedule your content in advance and automatically post it across Instagram, LinkedIn, Facebook, and more from one place.

    • Wish your content worked harder for you? → Easily repurpose each video into a blog post, email, or video message so your message gets seen across AI search, Google, and social feeds.

It’s a simple shift that can double your exposure – without doubling your time.

Whether you’re an individual loan officer or a national mortgage company, SocialCoach helps your team scale content, stay on brand, and stay visible to your audience.